Can You Freeze Key Lime Pie? – Easy Guide On Frozen Key Lime Pie – How Long Does It Last?

Can You Freeze Key Lime Pie?: Key Lime Pie, a traditional American dessert, is made with Graham Crackers and yellow custard, and it’s sweet while also being tart, which is why everyone likes it, whether it’s from American Africa or Asian countries; it crosses all borders and finds its way into people’s kitchens or refrigerators.

Also, it tends to be served cool, and it tastes good when served cool, but we can’t keep it at room temperature for a long time because it tends to harden and change texture, so it makes me wonder, Can I freeze key lime pie? You might wonder, too, if you’re facing the same problem as me, read this article.

Can You Freeze Key Lime Pie

What Is Key Lime Pie, Exactly? | Can You Freeze Key Lime Pie?

A dessert made primarily of egg yolks, key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and a graham cracker or pastry crust with a meringue or whipped cream topping. Unlike regular limes, they have a much stronger aroma as well, which is why it’s called key lime pie; however, it’s not too acidic.

Yes, you can freeze key lime pie as it is totally safe and it freezes without any changes. You just have to wrap them well so that you can freeze your key lime pie for up to 3 months. However, by using the simple method and surely enjoy this dessert at any time without regrets.

Related Posts:

How To Freeze Key Lime Pie?

First, allow your pie to cool to room temperature by setting it aside. Once it’s cooled enough, transfer it to a freezer-safe plate or container and place it in the freezer for 3–4 hours. After 3–4 hours, check your pie; if it’s turned solid, take it out. But if your freezer is slow, give it some more time to turn solid.

When you take your pie out of the freezer, wrap it properly with cling paper, making sure that no area of the pie is exposed to air. Wrap it in foil paper, place it in an airtight container or bag, and seal it properly, making sure to squeeze out all of the access air before sealing.

Now mark the container or bag with the help of a marker with a “best before” date so you can finish it on time and transfer your pie to the freezer. While placing it in the freezer, make sure the container or bag is not squeezed by other things in your freezer because it can damage the pie.

Tips For Achieving Good Results After Freezing Key Lime Pie

  • Don’t Top With Whipped Cream Or Meringue Before Freezing: You shouldn’t freeze your pie top with whipped cream or meringue because, when you freeze your pie, they freeze too in the refrigerator. When you try to thaw your pie, the topping will turn watery, so always top your pie once you have thawed it properly.
  • Cut Your Pie Into Pieces: If you’re getting late or have cravings, then cut your pie into pieces. It will make the thawing process faster than the usual one, and you can cut your pie before freezing it because it will allow you to take only the portion you need. You don’t have to thaw all the pie at once, but make sure you wrap all the pieces separately.
  • Warp Carefully: Don’t wrap pies too tightly with cling paper as it can damage your pie, so you should wrap your pie thoroughly.

How To Defrost Key Lime Pie?

You can thaw your pie by placing it on a countertop or in the fridge from the freezer for overnight thawing a day before you want to eat it; however, make sure you have uncovered it first, as if you don’t, your pie may be unsuitable for you.

Do Check:

Can Key Pie Be Re-Frozen?

Yes, you can freeze your pie multiple times, but we don’t recommend it because it’s only freezer-good once if you haven’t thawed it; after that, it will degrade its texture and taste due to moisture that developed during the thawing process, but it’s still safe to eat.

Do Key Lime Pie Freeze Well?

Yes, key lime pie freezes well, and it’s also best served cold because it tastes better that way. Because all of the ingredients in Key lime pie are safe to freeze, there’s no harm in freezing this delicious dessert, and no one can tell the difference between the frozen and fresh versions.

How Much Time Does Key Lime Pie Stay In The Freezer?

If you have made or purchased your pie in bunches and want to store it for a longer time like months then freezing helps you more. Because using the freezer method, which will allow your pie to stay safe for up to 3 months. If you want to store your pie for a few days, then preserving it in the fridge using a container or bag is the best option.

As we all know that bacteria love to grow when any food item sits at room temperature for a longer time. So, here key lime pie can stay fresh at room temperature for 5–6 hours.

Must Read:

FAQs Related to Can I Freeze Key Lime Pie?

1. Do I Put Key Lime Pie In The Fridge Or Freezer?

If you want to store your leftover pie for 4-5 days, you can store it in the fridge, but if you want to keep it for longer, you can freeze it.

2. Do You Reheat Key Lime Pie?

As previously stated, the key lime pie tastes best when served cold, so there is no need to reheat your pie.

3. Does Freezing A Key Lime Pie Ruin It?

No, freezing Kie Line pie did not ruin it because it freezes well, but you should make sure you freeze it properly or it will ruin your pie.

4. Can You Freeze Baked Or Unbaked Pies?

You can freeze your pie baked or unbaked, whatever you prefer most, but the thing is, you can store your unbaked pie for up to 2 months, but in the case of baked pie, you freeze it for 3 months.

Final Words.

If the dessert that people like to eat cool is delicious and freezes well, then why not freeze it for our guests or family members so we can serve them fresh key lime pie? That is the only reason we have shared this freezing method with you. Also, if you want to freeze other foods as well but don’t know how to do it, don’t worry; we are here to help.

You only need to go to our website,, where we have answered all of your questions. Also, if you have any questions about freezing key lime pie, please leave them in the comments section.

Leave a Comment